New Castle High School Hall of Fame Criteria
- Athlete - may be nominated 25 years after graduation
- Coach - may be nominated 10 years after out of coaching
- Contributor - may be nominated at any time
New Castle High School Wall of Fame Criteria
- A North Central Conference selection with in your respective sport.
- A North Central Conference event champion.
- A State qualifier
- A North Central Conference team champion.
- A post season tournament champion